Skip to content
Market Basics

Rent or buy: the comparison done honestly

Most versions of this argument compare an EMI with a rent. The real comparison is between two portfolios — and it turns on costs nobody puts in the spreadsheet.

Market BasicsBeginner13 min read
Browse Market Basics(163)

Almost every rent-versus-buy argument in India compares a monthly EMI with a monthly rent, notices the EMI builds an asset, and stops. That comparison is not wrong so much as incomplete: it leaves out the money the buyer sank on day one, the money the renter could have invested instead, and roughly 8% of the property price that disappears into stamp duty and registration before anyone moves in.

Think of it like this
Two families, same street

Two families live in identical flats in the same building. One pays ₹28,000 a month to a landlord. The other pays ₹44,000 to a bank. After ten years the second family owns a flat and the first owns nothing — unless you ask what the first family did with the ₹16,000 gap and the ₹25 lakh they never had to put down.

In the market

The comparison is only fair if the renter actually invests the difference. If the money is spent, buying wins almost automatically — not because property is the better asset, but because a loan is a forced savings plan.

The costs that decide it

CostTypical sizeWho pays itRecoverable?
Stamp duty and registration5–8% of priceBuyer, upfrontNo — gone the day you sign
Brokerage1–2%Buyer, and again when sellingNo
Interiors and fit-out5–15%BuyerVery little at resale
Maintenance and society charges~1% of value a yearOwnerNo
Property taxVaries by cityOwnerNo
Loan interestOften more than the price itselfBuyerPartly, via Section 24
Security deposit2–10 months of rentRenterYes, usually

Rental yield tells you what the market thinks

Rental yield = (Annual rent ÷ Property price) × 100
Annual rent
What the identical flat rents for, twelve months
Property price
What it would cost to buy today, all-in

Example: ₹28,000 a month on a ₹90 lakh flat = ₹3.36 lakh ÷ ₹90 lakh = 3.7%. In most Indian metros the figure sits between 2.5% and 3.5%.

A rental yield of 3% against a home loan rate of 8.5% means the market is pricing in appreciation. You are paying for growth that has not happened yet. That is not automatically a bad deal — but it is a very different deal from "rent is money down the drain", and it is worth knowing which one you are making.

Loading interactive demo…

Put your own city numbers in. Pay attention to what happens when you change the appreciation rate by a single percentage point — that one input moves the answer more than everything else combined.

What the spreadsheet cannot price

Reasons that are not returns
Genuine arguments for buying
  • No landlord can ask you to leave in a year
  • You can renovate, drill, keep a pet, age in place
  • A loan forces saving on people who would not otherwise save
  • Rent rises with inflation for life; an EMI is fixed in rupee terms and shrinks in real terms
  • Somewhere to live in retirement, when there is no salary to pay rent from
Genuine arguments for renting
  • You can move for a better job without selling anything
  • A flat is one asset in one city — the opposite of diversified
  • Selling takes months, and in a bad market, longer
  • No maintenance, no society politics, no leaking terrace
  • You are not concentrating twenty years of savings in one building
◆ Your call

The transfer

You are 31, renting in Pune, and about to buy a ₹85 lakh flat with a ₹17 lakh down payment. Two weeks before you sign, your company offers you a Bengaluru role with a 35% raise. You expect to be there at least four years.

Check yourself

A flat costs ₹1 crore and rents for ₹30,000 a month. The home loan rate is 8.5%. What is the market implicitly telling you?

Simple bhasha mein
Ghar ka sapna aur ghar ka hisaab

Har mummy-papa chahte hain ki bete ka apna ghar ho. Woh baat alag hai aur sahi hai. Par hisaab mein registry aur stamp duty ke aath percent ko mat bhoolo — woh paisa kahin nahi jaata, bas khatam ho jaata hai. Ghar lo kyunki settle hona hai, "investment" keh ke apne aap ko mat samjhao.

What to remember
  • The comparison is only honest if the renter actually invests the difference.
  • Roughly 8% of the purchase price vanishes into stamp duty, registration and brokerage.
  • Rental yields of 2.5–3.5% against 8.5% loans mean the price already assumes appreciation.
  • Section 24 relief only exists under the old tax regime — check which one you are in.
  • Mobility, stability and family are real reasons; they are just not investment returns.
You reached the endMark it done and keep your streak going.
Up nextThe emergency fund that has to come firstPrevious: How an index is actually built
Finished this lesson?

Mark it done to track your progress through the curriculum.

Common questions

Short, direct answers to what people ask about this topic.

rental yield meaning in indian property
Rental yield is the annual rent a property earns expressed as a percentage of what it would cost to buy today — twelve months of rent divided by the price, times 100. A ₹90 lakh flat renting at ₹28,000 a month yields about 3.7%. In most Indian metros the figure sits between 2.5% and 3.5%, well below home loan rates of around 8.5%, which means the price already assumes future appreciation.
how much of a flat price goes on stamp duty and registration
Stamp duty and registration typically take 5–8% of the property price in India, paid by the buyer on day one and recoverable never. Add brokerage of 1–2% on the way in, and again on the way out, and the transaction costs alone come to roughly 8% before anyone moves in. Rates are set by each state, so the exact figure depends on where the flat is and, in several states, on whether the buyer is a woman.
a home loan is often described as forced savings because
Every EMI carries a principal component, so repaying the loan quietly builds equity in the flat whether or not the borrower has the discipline to invest. That is why buying often works out better in practice even where the arithmetic favours renting — the renter has to actually invest both the monthly difference and the down payment they never had to make, and most people spend it instead.
is it worth buying a flat if I might move cities in a few years
Over a short holding period the one-time costs dominate everything else: roughly 5–8% in stamp duty and registration, 1–2% brokerage each way, and fit-out spending that recovers very little at resale. The property has to appreciate enough to clear all of that before ownership is even level with renting. Mobility is the single strongest argument on the renting side, and a likely transfer is exactly the situation it covers.
imputed rent meaning for a self occupied house
Imputed rent is the rent an owner-occupier effectively pays to themselves — the money they would otherwise have handed a landlord for the same flat, and the only ongoing “income” a self-occupied home actually produces. It belongs in a rent-versus-buy comparison because leaving it out makes ownership look like a pure cost. Indian income tax treats the annual value of a self-occupied house as nil, so this notional rent is not taxed.