Skip to content
Risk & Psychology

The disposition effect: selling the winner, keeping the loser

Given one share that is up and one that is down, most people sell the winner and keep the loser — locking in a small pleasure and postponing a pain. Why it happens, what the research found, what it can cost in tax, and the one question that cuts through it.

Risk & PsychologyIntermediate11 min read
Browse Risk & Psychology(133)

You need ₹7,000 for an expense. You hold two shares. One is up 30%; the other is down 30%. Which do you sell? Most people sell the winner — it feels good to book a profit, and selling the loser would mean admitting a mistake and making the loss real. It is one of the most consistently measured patterns in how individual investors behave, and on average it is the wrong way round.

Think of it like this
Dropping the batsman in form

A selector who drops the batsman scoring runs, to give another chance to the one out of form “until he gets back to his average”, is not managing a team — he is avoiding the discomfort of admitting a selection went wrong.

In the market

Selling the share that is working and keeping the one that is not, until it “gets back to cost”, is the same decision with money. The price you paid is not a target the market knows about.

What the research found

The economists Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman named the disposition effect in 1985. In 1998 Terrance Odean studied thousands of trading accounts at a US discount broker and found that investors sold winning shares much more readily than losing ones — and that the winners they sold went on, on average, to do better than the losers they kept. The pattern has since been found among investors in many countries. It is loss aversion acted out: selling a winner books a gain, selling a loser books a loss, and the loss is the one people avoid.

Worked example
Two shares, ₹7,000 needed
Illustrative holdings, each bought at ₹100 a share, 100 shares, held under a year
Share A: now ₹130a ₹3,000 paper gainWorth ₹13,000
Share B: now ₹70a ₹3,000 paper lossWorth ₹7,000
Sell 54 of A at ₹130realises a ₹1,620 short-term gain₹7,020 raised
Tax at 20% on that gainshort-term equity rate as of 2026; verify current rules≈ ₹324 to pay
Or sell all of B at ₹70realises a ₹3,000 short-term loss₹7,000 raised
That loss can be set off against other gainsif you have ₹3,000 of short-term gainsup to ₹600 of tax saved
Selling the winner usually creates tax; selling the loser can reduce it. But tax is the smaller point. The real question is which of the two you would buy today if you held cash instead. If the answer is A, selling A to keep B is paying to keep the share you believe in less.
Check yourself

You bought a share at ₹500. It is now ₹350, and after re-reading the results you would not buy it today. The best reason to keep it would be:

Simple bhasha mein
Form wala batsman bahar, out of form andar

Do share: ek 30% upar, ek 30% neeche. Paise chahiye toh zyada log jeetne wala bech dete aur haarne wala rakh lete — "cost pe aane do". Research mein mila ki jo winners beche gaye woh aksar baad mein un losers se behtar chale jo rakhe gaye. Tax bhi: winner bechne pe tax lagta, loser bechne ka loss doosre gains mein adjust ho sakta. Ek sawaal poochho: agar aaj cash hota, kya yeh share is daam pe kharidta? Kharid-daam sirf aapke liye maayne rakhta hai, bazaar ke liye nahi.

What to remember
  • Most investors sell winners too early and hold losers too long — the disposition effect.
  • Research found the winners sold often went on to beat the losers kept.
  • Selling winners usually creates tax; realised losses can be set off against gains.
  • Ask of every holding: would I buy it today at this price? Ignore what you paid.

Your notes

Private · saved on this device

Common questions

Short, direct answers to what people ask about this topic.

disposition effect meaning
The disposition effect is investors’ tendency to sell shares that have risen and hold on to shares that have fallen. It was named by the economists Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman in 1985. It comes from loss aversion and the wish to avoid regret: selling a winner books a pleasant gain, while selling a loser turns a paper loss into a real one, so it is put off.
should I sell my winning stock or losing stock first
Ask of each holding: if I had the cash today instead of the share, would I buy it at this price? Keep the ones you would buy and sell the ones you would not — whether they show a profit or a loss is irrelevant to that question. Tax often favours selling the loser first, because a realised loss can be set off against gains, while selling a winner creates tax to pay.
is it bad to hold a stock until it gets back to my buying price
Usually, yes, as a rule. The price you paid means nothing to the market or to the company’s future. Waiting to “get back to cost” keeps money in a holding for a reason unrelated to its prospects, and it can take years. Judge the share on what it is worth now and what you expect from it, as if you were buying it today.